Instagram and TikTok stand tall as two influential forces in the dynamic landscape of social media. TikTok vs Instagram influencers are among the most influential figures in our society.
Instagram, the seasoned veteran, has a rich history as the old player with a diverse range of content formats, appealing to a broad age spectrum. This versatility provides brands with an expansive canvas to craft and customize their marketing strategies.
On the other hand, TikTok, the vibrant newcomer, has rapidly seized the spotlight, captivating the world with its niche audience and unparalleled potential for content virality. But these aren’t the only differences between the two social media giants. Let’s elaborate.
Difference Between TikTok and Instagram
Instagram and TikTok have different algorithms, marketing strategies, and opportunities for brands. Instagram (currently in the lead) is a powerful content marketing, affiliate marketing, and influencer marketing platform for brands. It allows brands to create high-quality visual content, build a loyal community, and leverage the established influencer culture.
Despite being new-ish, TikTok is an excellent platform for viral marketing, user-generated content (UGC), and brand awareness. It enables authentic brand content, massive audience reach, and influencer culture engagement.
Let’s dig further into the specific differences between the two.
1. Advertising Dynamics
TikTok doesn’t have a separate feed for ads, instead, ads are shown as regular videos that blend in with the organic content. This requires advertisers to create ads that look and feel like native TikTok videos, rather than traditional commercials.
Some of the features that make TikTok ads more natural and engaging are:
- Popular music, sounds, filters, stickers, and effects.
- Vertical video format that fills the entire screen.
- Captions, hashtags, and calls to action invite the viewers to interact with the brand or the product.
- User-generated content that showcases real people and authentic experiences.
Instagram’s advertising strategies revolve around a structured and diverse approach, providing various content formats within a designated ad space. Advertisers on Instagram stick to a traditional model, lacking the seamless integration seen on TikTok. Despite this, Instagram ads come with distinctive benefits, supporting diverse formats and music integration, albeit not matching TikTok’s immersive sound experience.
2. Content Format
When it comes to content, TikTok excels in short-form video content, featuring concise and engaging videos. The platform’s algorithm personalizes each user’s experience through a unique “For You” page based on preferences and behavior. TikTok’s content is all about being creative with music, dance, and different types of entertainment. This emphasis on brevity and creativity positions TikTok as a hub for dynamic and trending content, frequently driven by challenges and trends.
In contrast, Instagram provides a broader selection of content formats, including photos, carousels, stories, reels, IGTV, and live videos. Its algorithm highlights content from followed users and suggests posts through the “Explore” page, offering users a variety of visually appealing experiences.
3. User Demographics: TikTok’s Younger Audience vs IG’s More Demographically Diverse Audience
Both platforms have slightly different user bases. Most TikTok users (47%) are under 30 years of age. It has more Gen Z influencers and users than Instagram and Snapchat and more than half of TikTok’s users worldwide are women (57%). The majority of female users fall within the 18-24 age range.
On the other hand, Instagram influencers cater to a more diverse demographic—ranging from teenagers to adults. The gender distribution is more evenly split, with 48.4% female and 51.6% male users.
Instagram attracts both Millennials and Gen Z, with users generally leaning slightly towards an older demographic compared to TikTok.
4. User Interaction
Interaction on Instagram often involves liking, commenting, and sharing content. Users engage through conversations in the comments section and direct messages. IG also has features like IGTV and Shopping to enhance user interaction.
Users on TikTok engage using content.TikTok promotes duets, stitches, and reactions, providing users with the tools to engage, collaborate, and remix each other’s content. Users frequently craft content in response to trending challenges, creating a vibrant, interconnected, and ongoing content ecosystem.
5. Influencer Marketing Dominance
Despite TikTok’s rapid growth, Instagram remains a dominant force in influencer marketing for two main reasons. Its advanced features offer a seamless shopping experience—with shoppable posts, product tags, and checkout options. Plus, Instagram’s diverse range of content formats allows influencers to showcase their personality and expertise through a variety of content formats.
These differences between the two platforms affect how influencers operate on them. Here are five key differences between TikTok and IG influencers.
TikTok vs Instagram Influencers: The 5 Key Differences
1. Their Goals
TikTok influencers aim to make their content go viral, gain popularity, and achieve fame on the platform. They create content to reach the “For You Page,” which is where the majority of users discover new content. The more views, likes, comments, and shares their videos get, the more successful they consider themselves. To expand their reach and opportunities, TikTok influencers often collaborate with other creators and partner with brands.
In contrast, Instagram influencers focus on building a strong reputation, demonstrating authority in their niche, and fostering loyalty among their followers. They achieve this by creating content that establishes trust, encourages engagement, and creates a sense of community.
For Instagram influencers, the ultimate goal is to turn their influence and expertise into tangible opportunities, whether it’s through selling products, offering services, or collaborating on sponsored posts.
2. Polished Instagram Content vs Original TikTok Content:
TikTok influencers steer away from extensive touch-ups and are highly valued for their authentic and unfiltered content. Plus the culture on TikTok is more casual. You may often see TikTok creators joining challenges and trends, making the platform a fun, and friendly place. The platform’s video editing features and filters also enhance this genuine style.
On the flip side, Instagram influencers thrive on versatility. They showcase their creativity through posts, Stories, and Reels. This multifaceted approach allows for a more polished and professional look and attracts a broad range of audiences.
Moreover, Creating polished content with filters and effects enhances visual storytelling, adding sophistication to the influencer culture on IG.
3. Marketing Strategies:
On Instagram, influencers humanize their content by sharing meticulously crafted images, behind-the-scenes moments, and posts—this also encourages interaction on the platform. For example, IG influencers often share some of their daily life, like trying on different outfits and giving sneak peeks into their fashion choices.
They also prefer to involve followers by asking about their favorite fashion trends through polls or questions, adding a personal touch, and making their content more interactive.
In contrast, TikTok influencers focus on being “themselves”. They actively engage in the latest trends and challenges, encouraging a sense of community among individuals who share similar interests or values, ultimately creating a welcoming and inclusive atmosphere. This makes user-generated content a standout feature on TikTok.
4. Editing Capabilities
TikTok is an extremely user-friendly platform with many built-in features. It has a huge collection of sounds, including funny clips, famous skits, hit songs, and original tracks. In-app features allow you to seamlessly incorporate any audio while making videos.
This makes it easy to create and edit videos and sounds right from your phone. Thanks to these advanced editing features, TikTok influencers have mastered the art of using both video and audio elements and creating professional-looking videos without the need for external editing tools.
Instagram, however, offers limited editing and filtering options for videos. So heavy editing required influencers to use external tools and apps. Even though they have introduced some competing editing features for Reels, like audio, speed, effects, and timer, these options are still limited compared to TikTok.
5. Influencer Preferences
As mentioned above, TikTok influencers focus a lot on the latest trends and challenges, creating videos using features like stitches, and duets. This keeps them connected with their audience.
On Instagram, engagement is not as dependent on the latest trends. While this allows collaborations to be more timeless, it might not be as exciting for younger users who prefer the constantly changing trends on TikTok.
Understand the Difference—Make Better Decisions
Both platforms are unique and both have a lot to offer. While considering marketing benefits you need to align your approach with your brand values, product, and overall objectives.
If you want to tap into creative expression and dynamic trends, partner up with TikTok influencers for spontaneous short-form video content and authentic engagement. However, if your brand promotion relies on content formats beyond videos, Instagram influencers are the ideal choice.
Understanding the unique strengths of each platform allows you to leverage their specific advantages and connect with your target audience effectively.
At Glewee, we can help you find your perfect social media platform partner or influencer. Opt for influencers from our carefully curated list to kickstart your marketing initiatives.